‘Blind Side’ Lawsuit Shows Strains in Depiction of Black Athletes

There’s a scene within the movie “The Blind Side” that intends to be an uplifting second of triumph. Michael Oher, a proficient offensive lineman who’s Black, is struggling in a highschool soccer apply, and in steps Leigh Anne Tuohy, a white girl who pulls him apart for a pep discuss.

Tuohy, who within the film’s retelling took Oher into her house after recognizing him strolling on the aspect of a Memphis-area highway on a chilly, damp night, recounts an earlier scene during which he had protected her from drug sellers in a “horrible part of town.” She instructs him to consider that when he’s doing his responsibility — defending the quarterback’s blind aspect — and to consider the quarterback and working again as herself and her organic son, Sean Jr.

“Protect the family, Michael,” Tuohy, portrayed by Sandra Bullock within the 2009 movie, says.

Oher takes the recommendation and the apply turns right into a montage of his extraordinary bodily capabilities. He earns raucous approval from his teammates and the bewildered happiness of his coach, because of Tuohy’s familial recommendation.

In actual life, Oher — who’s suing Leigh Anne and Sean Tuohy, the Memphis couple that took him into their household when he was 16 — has lengthy mentioned he knew extra about soccer than the film steered. And his lawsuit filed this week accused the Tuohys of exaggerating the specifics of their relationship and of deceptive him into signing away his life story for his or her profit.

On Wednesday, legal professionals for the Tuohys mentioned the household would agree to finish a conservatorship that started when Oher was 18, however that it had been clear all alongside that Oher, 37, had not been adopted. Marty Singer, one of many Tuohys’ legal professionals, mentioned in a press release that it “defies belief” that the household would swindle Oher after incomes tons of of tens of millions of {dollars} within the restaurant enterprise.

The association of the conservatorship is a central query within the case, together with the cash earned within the perpetuation of the story of the Tuohys and Oher.

Michael Lewis, the writer of the e book that the film is predicated on, “The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game,” mentioned in an interview when requested in regards to the latest dispute and the lawsuit that he was saddened and surprised by Oher’s claims.

“What was such a loving event is being turned into something so sad, and it’s so unnecessary,” mentioned Lewis, who was a childhood buddy of Sean Tuohy. “There were no millions of dollars of movie money that either I or the Tuohys got.”

The movie rights offered for $250,000, of which Lewis mentioned he saved $70,000 and gave $70,000 to the Tuohys, who cut up it 5 methods between the members of the family, together with Oher. Over the subsequent 15 years, Lewis mentioned he and the household acquired extra funds, largely from internet income, that added as much as some $280,000 for Lewis and $280,000 for the Tuohys.

For many viewers, the film’s depiction — like many dramatized Hollywood tales that stretch the reality and transcend the artistic management of the topics — embodied a well-recognized trope of Black athletes like Oher being extra bodily than mentally gifted, and needing white folks like Leigh Anne Tuohy to assist them alongside the best way.

“The Leigh Anne Tuohy character plays the white savior trope to a T,” mentioned Jeffrey Montez de Oca, a professor of sociology on the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs, who has researched the intersection of sports activities and popular culture.

“The Blind Side,” which received Bullock an Academy Award for her function, earned greater than $300 million on the field workplace and has had endurance as one of the well-liked sports activities films ever, incomes numerous reruns on cable tv.

But it has come below fireplace as moviegoers and critics have more and more scrutinized portrayals of Black Americans, together with athletes, in well-liked tradition, expressing considerations that many Black viewers and others raised when the film was first launched.

“‘The Blind Side’ traded, in many ways, on the stereotyped vision of the, let’s say, lost and helpless Black athlete and was able to succeed in part because the story was so familiar,” mentioned Kevin Wallsten, a professor of political science at California State University, Long Beach, who has researched the connection between racial resentment and opposition towards paying faculty athletes.

Oher, performed by Quinton Aaron within the film, is depicted as supremely athletic however missing the psychological acuity to grasp soccer’s complexities, and normally needing the assistance of different — white — characters. In one scene, Sean Tuohy Jr., a baby on the time, walks Oher by means of a collection of performs on a eating desk utilizing saltshakers and condiments as stand-ins for gamers on the gridiron.

Oher has mentioned that the portrayal affected how N.F.L. groups considered him, harming his profession. Before the 2009 draft, the ESPN analyst Todd McShay mentioned he had acquired two unfavorable reviews from groups regarding Oher’s character and referred to as him one of many riskiest potential draftees.

“References to the use of ketchup bottles being my knowledge of the game — a scene many will remember from the movie — would make many of the teams hesitant,” Oher mentioned in his new memoir, “When Your Back’s Against The Wall.”

About 20 years have handed since Oher first stepped on the sphere at Briarcrest Christian School in actual life, earlier than the Tuohys took him in. Plenty has modified since then. Oher has earned practically $35 million enjoying within the N.F.L., received a Super Bowl and fathered 4 youngsters. The nation’s understanding of the inherent racial dynamics in sports activities has modified, too.

“It’s an entirely different context, and it’s fascinating to watch American culture revisit the story of ‘The Blind Side’ with this 20-year interlude,” Wallsten mentioned.

A 1993 paper revealed in The Sociology of Sport Journal discovered that faculty college students thought Black student-athletes have been much less clever, acquired worse grades and weren’t academically ready to attend faculty, in comparison with white athletes.

One of Wallsten’s papers, co-authored with Tatishe Nteta and Lauren McCarthy, discovered {that a} slight improve of help for paying faculty athletes between 2014 and 2020 was pushed by altering opinions on racial points amongst white liberals.

Oher mentioned in his lawsuit that one of the hurtful revelations about his relationship with the Tuohys was that they by no means absolutely adopted him, as he believed they’d and as that they had claimed repeatedly.

The e book and the film echoed the paternalistic impression.

“Leigh Anne Tuohy was trying to do for one boy what economists had been trying to do, with little success, for less developed countries for the last fifty years,” Lewis mentioned within the e book. “Kick him out of one growth path and onto another. Jump-start him.”

Alexandra Alter contributed reporting.