Inside the Garrick, the Elite Men-Only London Club Rocked by Criticism

On a aspect avenue in Covent Garden stands an imposing palazzo-style constructing, unusually misplaced amid the burger joints and neon marquees of London’s theater district. It homes the Garrick Club, considered one of Britain’s oldest males’s golf equipment, and on any given weekday, a lunch desk in its baronial eating room is among the hottest tickets on the town.

A customer fortunate sufficient to cadge an invite from a member would possibly find yourself within the firm of a Supreme Court justice, the grasp of an Oxford faculty or the editor of a London newspaper. The odds are that particular person could be a person. Women are excluded from membership within the Garrick and permitted solely as company, a long-simmering supply of stress that has not too long ago erupted right into a full-blown furor.

After The Guardian, a London newspaper, put a recent highlight on the Garrick’s men-only coverage, naming and shaming a few of its rarefied members from a leaked membership checklist, two senior British authorities officers resigned from the membership: Richard Moore, the chief of the Secret Intelligence Service, and Simon Case, the cupboard secretary, who oversees practically half 1,000,000 public staff.

Only days earlier, underneath questioning at a Parliamentary listening to, Mr. Case defended his membership by saying he was attempting to reform an “antediluvian” establishment from inside moderately “than chuck rocks from the outside,” a line that provoked derisory laughs. Mr. Moore’s membership appeared at odds together with his efforts to convey extra racial and gender range to the British spy company, referred to as MI6.

Now, the membership’s 1,300 members are debating the way forward for the Garrick over lamb chops within the eating room, after-dinner drinks within the lounge underneath the principle staircase and in a WhatsApp group, the place they swap fretful messages concerning the newest developments. Some welcome the strain to confess girls as lengthy overdue; others lament that doing so would ceaselessly change the character of the place.

“The Garrick Club has an absolute right to decide who its members are,” stated Simon Jenkins, a columnist at The Guardian and a former editor of The Times of London who’s a longtime member. “That said, it is indefensible for any social club these days not to have women as members.”

“Judi Dench, for God’s sake — why shouldn’t she be a member?” he added.

Or Jude Kelly, an award-winning former theater director. Ms. Kelly, who now runs the charity Women of the World, stated that excluding girls from membership within the Garrick disadvantaged them of entry to an elite social circle the place skilled alternatives inevitably flowed with the brandy.

“We’re in 2024,” Ms. Kelly stated. “These are incredibly senior people. Many of them are espousing diversity and inclusion in their professional lives. Being on the inside for a long time makes you complicit.”

The Garrick Club will not be the one non-public membership in London that doesn’t admit girls: White’s, Boodle’s, the Beefsteak Club and the Savile Club are additionally males solely. But what makes the Garrick distinctive is its star-studded membership checklist, which ranges throughout the worlds of politics, regulation, arts, theater and journalism.

Members, primarily based on The Guardian’s leaked checklist, embrace the actors Benedict Cumberbatch, Brian Cox and Stephen Fry; Mark Knopfler, the guitarist of the rock band Dire Straits; Paul Smith, the style designer; the BBC correspondent John Simpson; Oliver Dowden, Britain’s deputy prime minister; and, sure, King Charles III (on an honorary foundation).

The boldfaced names have lent the dispute additional piquancy, particularly since lots of them would appear the sort of bien-pensant progressives who would abhor any sort of discriminatory coverage. Indeed, Mr. Cox, Mr. Fry and Mr. Simpson are amongst those that have come out publicly in favor of admitting girls.

The final time the members voted on the query, in 2015, a slender majority — 50.5 % — stated they supported it. But the membership’s bylaws require a two-thirds majority to vary the coverage on membership, and a brand new vote, if it had been scheduled, wouldn’t be held till the summer time. A membership official declined to touch upon the matter.

For all of the misgivings that members have about not admitting girls, some predict they’d nonetheless fail to achieve the two-thirds threshold. The dispute has, maybe inevitably, turned bitter, pitting a handful of dedicated campaigners towards a bigger, older group, lots of whom are effective with girls as company however are reluctant to rock a ship that has sailed grandly since 1831.

In New York City, non-public golf equipment just like the Union League and the Century Association started admitting girls within the Nineteen Eighties, typically underneath the strain of authorized judgments. But in London, the place golf equipment just like the Garrick are extra zealous about being social moderately than skilled networking establishments, defenders argue that the case for preserving male-only membership is extra justifiable.

These members say they go to the Garrick to drink wine, unwind and revel in themselves. They crack jokes they wouldn’t make in blended firm. They will not be allowed to conduct enterprise; even pulling papers out of a briefcase is seemed down upon.

Some dismissed it as a tempest in a teapot. Jonathan Sumption, a lawyer and former justice within the Supreme Court, stated he supported the admission of ladies, however added that those that opposed it had been entitled to their opinion.

“The Garrick Club is not a public body and the whole issue is too unimportant to make a fuss of,” Mr. Sumption stated. “It is still a pretty good club.”

Mr. Jenkins, the columnist, agreed, suggesting that among the news protection had caricatured the Garrick as a vaguely sinister place the place males collect to plot towards girls. Women, he stated, had been welcome on the communal desk within the eating room, maybe the membership’s most hallowed place.

The solely room off limits to girls is the members’ lounge, referred to as Under the Stairs, the place males collect after dinner. Yet, as Ms. Kelly and different girls be aware, probably the most beneficial relationships are sometimes shaped in such casual settings.

To that extent, the Garrick is totally different from White’s, an much more unique males’s membership in St. James’s, the place Queen Elizabeth II was the one girl ever invited as a visitor. When President Donald J. Trump’s ambassador to Britain, Robert Wood Johnson IV, held lunches there together with his senior workers, he couldn’t invite his personal political counselor as a result of she was a girl. Female staff on the embassy complained to the State Department, and he was urged to finish the follow.

But White’s and its old-line, Conservative-friendly brethren “tend to be high Tory places, where the question wouldn’t arise,” stated Alan Rusbridger, a former editor of The Guardian, who resigned from the Garrick greater than a decade in the past.

“The Garrick membership is more a mix of actors, journalists and lawyers,” he stated. “Thus, it’s a more pertinent question.”